Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 12:30 am

by NWade

Hello All,

Tragedy struck today shortly after starting my AeroVee Turbo. Through 6 short engine runs it had provided smooth and strong power, hadn’t leaked oil, and the only sign of anything non-optimal was that I could only get ~36" MAP at WOT (but it was still making over 3000 RPM with my Prince prop).

On this run, I started the engine and got it idling for no more than ~5 seconds when my observer yelled “Oil! Lots of Oil!” I shut the engine down immediately and climbed out of the cockpit to see a HUGE puddle of oil below the airplane, and oil dripping from every item forward of the firewall.

After getting out the oil-dry and spreading it beneath the airplane, we started looking at the flow path of the oil around the crankcase to find the source of the problem. There were no obvious cracks, broken items, or loose hoses. But a bunch of the oil seemed to originate around the top-mount oil cooler itself. On a hunch, I double-checked that the mags & coils where off, then I slowly turned the prop by hand. After a couple of blades, a gob of oil burped out the front of the oil cooler - from somewhere between the first and second plates, down low on the pilot’s side. I waited until the cooler stopped “drooling”, then slowly pulled the prop around another 90 degrees of arc. Sure enough, another thimbleful of that green Brad Penn 20w-50 oil oozed out of the front of the oil cooler and dribbled down onto the crankcase.

After putting on my thinking cap while I spent 2 hours mopping up the worst of the oil in the engine compartment and scrubbing oil-dry around on the airport’s asphalt, I’ve come to the conclusion that I probably got a bad part from CBPerformance. The other likely explanation is that my oil pressure is a lot higher than I thought, and the system can’t take that much pressure. According to my VDO gauge, the oil pressure has been ~90 psi cold (air temps around 42 degrees F), with the pressure dropping to 50 psi once the engine has been running for 2-3 minutes. This seems a little bit on the high side, but not excessively so (unless my gauge is way off).

  • Has anyone else ever experienced this failure?
  • Does anyone have a recommended cleaner/degreaser that won’t damage the insulation on the electrical wires in my engine compartment?
  • Anyone have a way to get oil out of the exhaust wrap?
    (My guess is that I’ll have to remove it and buy new stuff, as a couple of sections are absolutely saturated)
  • Have a proven/approved method of slightly lowering the oil pressure in the AeroVee?
    (Cut the spring on the oil control plunger? Get a different spring? Something else?)

Thanks,

–Noel
(…who’s not looking forward to removing the fence baffles and some of the wiring and the intake system and the aeroinjector to clean it all off)


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 3:22 am

by lutorm

Wow. At least it happened on the ground!

I’ve heard of VW oil cooler failures due to overpressure, but they have been to the ones mounted in the “full-flow filter circuit”, ie our bottom-mounted cooler. Since these are mounted before the pressure-relief valve in the case, they will see whatever pressure the pump is capable of putting out, which if the oil is cold can be very high (and does not show up on the pressure gauge since it is mounted after the filter.)

But it sounds like this is a top-mounted cooler, which should be after the pressure relief so shouldn’t ever see those unregulatedly high pressures. (Unless your pressure relief piston is stuck, which would be a good thing to check.) Did you happen to record oil pressure data on this very run? 90 psi is a lot higher than what we had on our bottom-cooled Aerovee at “cold” (ie, 75F…) starts before I tore it down, but with gigantic bearing clearances and complete flow through the oil cooler bypass this engine still saw ~70psi. 90 should not blow a cooler, I’d think, so maybe it was a bad cooler. It seems easy to get VW parts of questionable quality…

An easy way to lower the oil pressure is to switch to a less viscous oil. In the auto world, not many seem to run 20w-50 in their VW’s. 10w-30 seems much more common, certainly if the temperatures are down near freezing. Maybe since we run the engines at high power for long periods of time maybe they run at higher temperatures than in cars, so more viscous oil is warranted?


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 5:41 am

by rizzz

90 PSI is very high,
I think I get mid 60’s to low 70’s cold and mid 30’s hot.
Definetly check the pressure relief pistons, they can get stuck and if you find it is, GP has instructions on their website somewhere to get it out.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 8:41 am

by Area 51%

Have you identified the type of failure yet? Thin material? Bad seam? Seal failure?

While dry-fitting my oil cooler to the engine, I noticed that the cooler was contacting the engine case bolt boss under it.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 10:20 am

by marsolgp

Noel, I had the exact same failure last year… Makes a pretty good mess, huh?.. My oil pressures run about the same as yours… just chocked it up to another bad aftermarket VW part. I removed the cooler and blocked it off with the bypass plate and flew the rest of the ‘winter’ season that way. Don’t really need a cooler in the winter.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 11:54 am

by 9GT

No help here with your oil cooler but something that REALLY works well for de-greasing and is safe for your wiring is Super Clean available at most big box stores including Wal-Mart. https://www.walmart.com/ip/SuperClean-T … 3=&veh=sem
Comes in a purple jug in various sizes right down to a squirt/spray bottle. Don’t confuse it with Purple Power which is lame in comparison. Once you try Super Clean you’ll want to keep it on hand at all times.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 12:12 pm

by NWade

Thanks, all!

For the record, and to answer some of the questions:

An easy way to lower the oil pressure is to switch to a less viscous oil

The only “approved” oil for the AeroVee Turbo is Brad Penn 20w-50 Racing oil (semi-synthetic). :-/

Definetly check the pressure relief pistons

I’ll do that once things are cleaned up; but when assembling the engine I made sure that the slugs slid smoothly up and down in their channels with just a bit of oil on ‘em. But I guess that once they were installed with the honkin’ springs behind them, they might have gotten jammed… Will investigate and report!

Have you identified the type of failure yet? Thin material? Bad seam? Seal failure?
While dry-fitting my oil cooler to the engine, I noticed that the cooler was contacting the engine case bolt boss under it.

No, not yet. The failed area is between two of the horizontal plates, somewhere back from the “leading edge” so its not visible. I’ve brought some parts home - including the fialed cooler - to try to drain and clean them. I’ll see if I can find the exact point of failure once its cleaned up. As for my cooler, it never contacted the crankcase once it was mounted on the adapter plate with the oil seals in-place.

Will be calling Sonex momentarily to also get their opinion, and will report my findings here if there’s anything noteworthy.

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 3:53 pm

by lutorm

NWade wrote:Thanks, all!
The only “approved” oil for the AeroVee Turbo is Brad Penn 20w-50 Racing oil (semi-synthetic). :-/

Indeed. I don’t think there are any “approved” methods of lowering the oil pressure… :wink:

As long as you have sufficient oil pressure on hot idle, a less viscous oil is unlikely to cause a problem. (Some people even say higher-viscosity oils run hotter, because the increased viscosity leads to increased oil cooler pressure and more oil bypassing it.)


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2018 7:06 pm

by kmacht

Carefully with what you clean it with. Make sure it is safe for aluminum and use lots and lots of water. I like simple green but it has to be the one for aviation. The regular one found in home depot isn’t good for aluminum.

Keith
#554


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 4:35 pm

by NWade

Just for completeness:

I got a somewhat-brief response from Sonex today. Basically I was told that I can run a lower viscosity oil, but they have no suggestions/recommendations on what to put in. They also recommended I put in a mechanical oil pressure gauge to cross-check the VDO sender (the VDO sender I bought from them. The one which maxes out at only 80 psi, so you can’t truly tell if you’re seeing excessive oil pressure). They also noted that I can run without an oil cooler in cold temps (but no comment on what temp range might be recommended for that mode of operation, or how I would go about modding the AeroVee to do this). They also recommended I idle the engine until the oil temp is above 80 degrees (which, of course, is exactly what I was trying to do when the oil cooler blew out).

:-/

Not being incredibly impressed with the depth of information I’m working with, I also read a bunch and posted on some VW forums. Many VW automotive solutions & standards are inappropriate for an aircraft applications. However, I wanted to see what they had to say and then make my own judgments based on my experience so far with the AeroVee and with automotive (racing) engines that I worked on in my youth. I got some great responses and some pretty useless responses (hey, its the internet). The two notable things I took away are -
(a) 20w-50 is claimed to be “too heavy” by many VW folks and has been known to blow out oil coolers. This is due to a combination of the stock oil galley size around the oil pressure relief plunger (which tries to bypass the oil through bearings and other narrow orifices), the heavier-than-stock oil-pressure-relief springs that come in modern VW kits, and the thick cold oil itself. AeroConversions undoubtedly has a reason why they want a thick oil in the engine (either to maintain high pressures with hot oil at high RPM, or to retain a thick oil film when the engine is not used for weeks at a time, or for some other reason). However I had my ear chewed off about how 20w-50 is excessive and unnecessary in an automotive application.
(b) Early VW oil pumps were smaller than modern pumps and the bigger aftermarket pumps people use now often require (or are heavily encouraged to use) oil pump covers with special pressure-relief passages, or remote bypass valves that are daisy-chained to remote oil filters. I find this info germane since the AeroVee Turbo seems to be using something similar to this CB Performance pump and I believe that pump flows more than the old 26mm stock unit.

So, here’s my current plan:
(Note that I don’t claim to know that these are the correct steps to take; just putting it on-record as what I am going to try)

  1. Clean everything with Simple Green Aircraft Cleaner
  2. Get a replacement oil cooler
  3. Switch to Brad Penn 15w-40 oil (still semi-synthetic with high ZDDP). VW automotive guys are encouraging me to switch to 10w-30 but I want to make incremental changes and not suddenly find myself dealing with low oil pressure when the engine is hot.
  4. Replace the 80 psi VDO sender from AeroConversions with a 120psi or 150psi VDO sender. I might lose a little bit of precision, but doing this will allow me to see if the engine is running up to excessive pressure levels on engine-start without having to run an oil line into the cockpit and set up a mechanical gauge.
  5. Pull the oil control and oil pressure relief plungers out and check the bores for signs that the springs are scraping or not moving freely. I don’t think this is an issue but I want to check to be sure. I tested the plungers themselves before assembling the engine and they slid smoothly and freely so I know they’re OK.
  6. Optional Bonus Fun - I’m really not a fan of the hard-line for oil that runs from the pressure sender to the crankcase flywheel flange. I’m going to look at converting that to a -4 AN braided hose and using an cushioned (Adel) clamp on the oil cooler attachment bolt to hold the hose in the proper orientation/shape (so it has a high point for oil to drain back, and so its own weight doesn’t apply a torque on the fittings to loosen up over time).

–Noel

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 5:27 pm

by Sonex422

I also have had an oil cooler failure last spring right after I converted to a top mounted oil cooler. It occurred during initial run-up and leak test. Initially I thought it was high Oil pressure because of the 90 psi reading on my MGL Stratomaster.

On examination of the failed oil cooler it was discovered that there was a poor weld between the corrugated fins and the chamber containing the oil.

After replacing the top mounted oil cooler and before starting the engine again I bought a direct reading test gage from Harbor freight with a long hose. After engine start it read in the normal 50 psi range. So I did some more research and found out that the MGL stratomaster defaulted to Rotax settings (probably should have done that earlier). Rotax uses a 200 PSI VDO gage. So I simply had to set the correct scaling factor in the Stratomaster. Once completed, the readings matched that of the test gauge. There have not been any oil system issues since then.

I hope that this may help.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 6:16 pm

by NWade

Sonex422 wrote:On examination of the failed oil cooler it was discovered that there was a poor weld between the corrugated fins and the chamber containing the oil.

…So I did some more research and found out that the MGL stratomaster defaulted to Rotax settings (probably should have done that earlier). Rotax uses a 200 PSI VDO gage

Thanks! Yeah, my Discovery Lite iEFIS defaulted to a 100psi gauge, and on my initial engine start I saw 100psi during the first few moments of running. Later on I realized I needed to adjust the EFIS and set it to the 80psi range of my VDO sender. From then on, I saw 80 psi during the first minute or two of each engine run. But I think my oil pressure may well be higher than that; its just beyond the max that the VDO sender can read. I’m curious to see what reading the 150psi VDO sender shows me on startup; if I can’t get a good consistent set of readings from it then I’ll grab a direct-read gauge from HF and see.

Either way, I’m making these series of changes just to be on the safe side. I’d hate to clean this mess up and then blow another oil cooler!

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 7:00 pm

by daleandee

NWade wrote:The one which maxes out at only 80 psi, so you can’t truly tell if you’re seeing excessive oil pressure). They also noted that I can run without an oil cooler in cold temps (but no comment on what temp range might be recommended for that mode of operation, or how I would go about modding the AeroVee to do this). They also recommended I idle the engine until the oil temp is above 80 degrees (which, of course, is exactly what I was trying to do when the oil cooler blew out).

When I had my VW powered nose roller I was returning back home from my second time flying to the ASA meeting in Crossville Tn. I was coming down the valley and had just crossed over into Georgia when I noticed the oil pressure at 80 PSI. At first I thought it must be a bad sender and then I considered that there might be a few people in the graveyard that thought that too. Straight ahead about 11 miles was Dalton (DNN) so I decided to land there and find out what the problem was. After landing I took a look at what I could see without pulling the cowling & did a run-up. Everything was absolutely normal. Unicom had called and asked if I needed assistance. I told then the concern but all seemed well and I was taking off but depending on how it went I might be right back. It never did that again …

NWade wrote:20w-50 is claimed to be “too heavy” by many VW folks and has been known to blow out oil coolers. This is due to a combination of the stock oil galley size around the oil pressure relief plunger (which tries to bypass the oil through bearings and other narrow orifices), the heavier-than-stock oil-pressure-relief springs that come in modern VW kits, and the thick cold oil itself.

I’m in the camp that believes that 20W50 may be too thick. While it’s true that air-cooled engines have larger clearances & tolerances change more because they run at a higher temp, oils are much better than they used to be and oil that is thick can’t flow well. Pressure is important but so is flow. The factory says they want to see something above 40 PSI on the engine. Then builders get into thinking if 40 is good then 50 is better! So they tend to set the oil piston spring pressure higher & use a heavy oil and at start up on a cold morning the oil pressure can really shoot up high if the engine has to be spun up to keep it running in the cold. Resist the temptation to set the pressure too high or use oil that is heavy. I like your approach below about trying a viscosity oil that is one step below what you are currently running. I use 15W40 Rotella and it works well but I rarely will be flying if the temps are near freezing. (I’m turning into a wimpy old geezer).

My Corvair engine uses a stock factory oil cooler. We generally test them to 80 PSI before using them. You might consider doing that … even with a new one. If your oil system is correctly set up you won’t need a sender that reads over 80PSI. If it’s reading that high, how high it is is not really a concern but getting the airplane on the ground is!

With your experience you are aware that they make an Oil Pressure Adjustable Pressure Regulator so you can set your oil pressure where you want it. As the engine breaks in you can reset it if needed.

Dunno if this helps,

Dale Williams
N319WF @ 6J2
Myunn - “daughter of Cleanex”
120 HP - 3.0 Corvair
Tail Wheel - Center Stick
Signature Finish 2200 Paint Job
166.7 hours / Status - Flying
Member # 109 - Florida Sonex Association

Latest Video - “I Wanna Fly” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VP7UYEqQ-g


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 8:21 pm

by hollandvw

Hi guys and gals The factory vws from the 70’s I.E. 1600 dual port (wich your engine is based on) recommended 10w30 in the winter and straight weight 30 in the summer changing bore and stroke has no effect on the oiling system or passages. I am not an expert but have built well over 50 vw engines in the 35 years I have been working on them and would never use anything but rotella 15w40 in the summer and 10w30 in the winter even on my turbo street engines. 20w50 in the winter has to be about like pumping 80-90 gear lube in the summer. Also I have never run a synthetic in a Aircooled vw as synthetics are designed to reject heat and 40% of your engines cooling comes from the oil. hope this helps Scott


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 9:22 pm

by NWade

Today I found out the hard way: mentioning 20w-50 on certain VW forums will get the sanctimonious a-holes there raging! sigh

Dale - I wasn’t aware of an adjustable pressure regulator for the VW; I’d be curious to see what that product looks like - have any links or product names I should look up?

My understanding (after dealing with some actually-helpful folks on the VW foums) is that the outflow of the oil cooler connects back to the main oil galleys, and there are no check-valves in the system. Therefore, even when the oil pressure spikes and the oil relief plunger opens up, the oil that bypasses the cooler still routes through the bearings and galleys and the end result is that the entire oil system still pressurizes. With no check-valves, oil can be forced to backflow up into the cooler until it reaches the same pressure as everywhere else. You get no real flow through the cooler; but you do get pressure in there.

Aftermarket VW folks have designed oil pumps that have pressure-relief ports that dump oil directly back into the sump, but those solutions are not usable on an AeroVee Turbo because of the double-stacked oil pump design we use.

Take care,

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2018 11:25 pm

by daleandee

NWade wrote:I wasn’t aware of an adjustable pressure regulator for the VW; I’d be curious to see what that product looks like - have any links or product names I should look up?

https://www.ebay.com/p/EMPI-9198-VW-Bug-Adjustable-Oil-Pressure-Regulator/1974594347

NWade wrote:Aftermarket VW folks have designed oil pumps that have pressure-relief ports that dump oil directly back into the sump, but those solutions are not usable on an AeroVee Turbo because of the double-stacked oil pump design we use.

I haven’t seen what Sonex is using but I have a '74 Beetle with an Auto-Stick that has a double stack oil pump. They are stacked together but are separate in their operation as the outer one is used to drive hydraulic fluid (Auto trans fluid) for the torque converter part of the Auto-Stick transmission setup. It really is a pretty good German design. Here’s a link to the VW pump:

https://www.evwparts.com/vwparts/113115101A.html

Dale Williams
N319WF @ 6J2
Myunn - “daughter of Cleanex”
120 HP - 3.0 Corvair
Tail Wheel - Center Stick
Signature Finish 2200 Paint Job
166.7 hours / Status - Flying
Member # 109 - Florida Sonex Association
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VP7UYEqQ-g


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 12:49 am

by NWade

daleandee wrote:

NWade wrote:I wasn’t aware of an adjustable pressure regulator for the VW; I’d be curious to see what that product looks like - have any links or product names I should look up?

https://www.ebay.com/p/EMPI-9198-VW-Bug-Adjustable-Oil-Pressure-Regulator/1974594347

Thanks! On the one hand that’s kludgy as hell; on the other hand its brilliantly simple. All that thing does is stop the oil control plunger from retracting all the way. So its good for helping keep the oil pressure higher. But sadly I can’t see how it would help lower the oil pressure below stock/standard levels; so it won’t help me at the present time.

Its good to know that exists, though. Thanks for sharing!

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 1:55 am

by lutorm

NWade wrote:Thanks! On the one hand that’s kludgy as hell; on the other hand its brilliantly simple. All that thing does is stop the oil control plunger from retracting all the way. So its good for helping keep the oil pressure higher. But sadly I can’t see how it would help lower the oil pressure below stock/standard levels; so it won’t help me at the present time.

I think it actually pushes the bottom of the spring up, changing the spring preload. But that still means you can’t use it to lower your the relief pressure except by also switching to a lighter spring.

And about the pressure relief valve still pressurizing the cooler: yeah, the cooler will always see the indicated oil pressure. But that pressure will be set by the pressure control valve at the rear of the case, not by whatever pressure is needed to squeeze the oil through the cooler. It’s the latter that can get really high, since the control valve will dump oil back to the sump if the pressure is higher than something like 35psi (I may be misremembering the pressure it relieves at.)

Edit: there is another situation that can lead to overpressure: if you use a 30mm or larger oil pump, the relief passages are apparently not large enough to relieve all the excess flow, so the pressure can spike to very high levels.

There’s an interesting thread at thesamba here: https://www.thesamba.com/vw/forum/viewtopic.php?t=280293 where some guy took pressure readings at different places in the oil system for a bunch of different conditions. Really useful for understanding how the oil pressure behaves.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 8:48 am

by Area 51%

CB performance has the oil cooler block-off/bypass plate. The part number is 1733 and it’s $17.95.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 10:33 am

by SonexN76ET

Noel,

I believe you may be over thinking the high oil pressure you experienced. Likely it is one of two things. Either your pressure relief plunger stuck or you had a defective oil cooler. Your’s is the only top mounted cooler I have heard of that has burst. Most Aerovee builders have the issue of trying to increase their oil pressure. Also as your engine starts to break in you will likely start to see your pressure come down and you will start looking for ways to increase your oil pressure. The device Dale wisely presented is a very commonly used solution.

Finally, in regards to oil, please disregard the advice from automotive VW experts who have never flown behind or operated or maintained a VW powered aircraft and rather follow the recommendations of the factory. The flying environment is completely different than the road environment. Flying stresses on an engine are more akin to driving uphill in a fully loaded truck on a steep grade with a constant heavy load on the engine and at relatively high constant rpm.

As a side note, I recommend you take Robert Hoover’s VW blog with a grain of salt. He was an enthusiastic VW hobbiest and someone with strong opinions who loved to write. He had nowhere near the experience of John Monnett, Great Planes, Hummel, or Rev-master. Some of his advice is bogus. For instance, his advice on painting VW engine cases does not work. I tried it and my paint peeled right off.

Jake

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 3:00 pm

by lutorm

SonexN76ET wrote:As a side note, I recommend you take Robert Hoover’s VW blog with a grain of salt. He was an enthusiastic VW hobbiest and someone with strong opinions who loved to write. He had nowhere near the experience of John Monnett, Great Planes, Hummel, or Rev-master.

I couldn’t tell whether you meant the preceding paragraph to apply to Bob Hoover as well but, just to be clear, he was also in the business of converting VW’s for aircraft use. As for who has the most experience, I wouldn’t know. Like anyone’s advice, his should be taken with a grain of salt.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 4:40 pm

by SonexN76ET

In regards to Robert Hoover’s VW blog, there is a huge difference between engineering and producing 1,500 plus engines like AeroConversions has with Robert Hoover helping to build a handful of engines.

I will give you another example of Robert Hoover’s bad advice. He recommends if your oil pressure relief plungers are sticking is to put valve grinding compound on them and to stick them back in your engine and spin them and push them up and down until they loosen up. Now, unless you are going to disassemble your engine there is not going to be a way to get that abrasive valve grinding compound out of the narrow oil galleys above the plungers.

Please be careful whose advice you follow.

Jake


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 5:13 pm

by kmacht

That specific advice was for during engine assembly when you could clean it out. I would treat every piece of advice as skeptical even if from the factory. They denied issues with the #4 bearing restrictor plug until they diddnt. Their mags were bad until suddenly they werent. They also have issues with the turbo but are still selling it without a fix in place. It’s always best to look at each piece of advice and see what their motivations might be. Sonex is trying to stay in business and sell motors. What was Bob Hoover’s motivation?

Keith


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 8:01 pm

by lutorm

In general, I’ve found most of Hoover’s topics to advocate a very careful, take no chances, approach to assembling a VW engine, arguing specifically that you can’t just buy a bunch of VW parts these days and think that they’ll go together without careful checking of all the specifications. Much more so than the impression you get from the Aerovee assembly manual. Is it all necessary? I don’t know, but you can’t fault the guy for being careless.

As an example, the Aerovee manual mentions nothing about checking the cam timing. Hoover does, and when I did, I found my cam to be 4 degrees off.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Jan 19, 2018 1:26 am

by gammaxy

lutorm wrote:As an example, the Aerovee manual mentions nothing about checking the cam timing. Hoover does, and when I did, I found my cam to be 4 degrees off.

You certainly pay a lot of attention to detail and I enjoy reading about it here and on your blog. Hoover makes it sound like you’ll have serious issues with 4 degrees of error, but the dyno charts I’ve found make the differences seem fairly minor (compared to the story he shared). I believe you’d need a dyno to determine what the optimal angle is in the first place since it depends on intake and exhaust design. If it is 4 degrees advanced, I’d probably be happy with it and wonder if it was intentional. 4 degrees retarded might require more research. In any case, it’s probably a good idea to sanity check these sorts of details to make sure you’re not off by a whole tooth or have a mis-machined camshaft, I just don’t take Hoover’s story and your measurement as evidence of an actual issue yet.
https://www.chevydiy.com/chevy-big-bloc … in-events/
http://forums.turbobricks.com/showthread.php?t=209648

Noel,
Sorry for getting off-topic on your thread. Hearing about your blown oil cooler is heart breaking. What a mess. I also have a top-mounted cooler with about 250 hours on it and have flown it a number of times in temperatures around freezing or a little lower (a couple of times this week, even). I run 20w50 but would be interested in something a little thinner. I’m thinking you must have received a bad cooler. I like the idea of pressure testing them before installation as was mentioned earlier, but don’t know what pressure I’d use. Let us know if you find anything on the cooler that could be inspected to detect a bad one.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Jan 19, 2018 9:48 am

by bvolcko38

On my Aerovee, with top mounted oil cooler, I had to file away a good 1/4" of the boss behind the oil cooler. The boss interfered with the cooler
BV


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Jan 19, 2018 12:00 pm

by pete 212

Hi for those with high oil pressure, I had an aerovee that blew 2 coolers 1 temp senders and some filters, then I put a mechanical press gauge on and got 250 yes 250 psi and the ONLY way to bring it down was to do everything on the last page of the samber link, you could take the relief out and grind a X about 1/16 deep on the top to get the oil the full diameter of the piston, having worked in hydraulics it made perfect sense. Pete212


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Jan 19, 2018 3:45 pm

by NWade

gammaxy wrote:I’m thinking you must have received a bad cooler. I like the idea of pressure testing them before installation as was mentioned earlier, but don’t know what pressure I’d use. Let us know if you find anything on the cooler that could be inspected to detect a bad one.

So I used lightly compressed air to confirm where the oil cooler lost integrity. I carefully used a Dremel cutoff wheel to slice away the lower plate on the cooler, and the photos show you what I found. Its definitely a structural failure and it appears to be from an over-pressure event. The photos don’t show it super-clearly, but its obvious that the end of the cooler where the flow wraps around between the bottom oil channel and the second oil channel distorted/swelled under pressure. The middle section of this piece held its shape while the material around it stretched, leading to a tear in the metal. There may be other failures in nearby areas that I didn’t uncover; this seems like a small hole for over 1 quart of oil to escape in ~10 seconds - but then again it was under a lot of pressure! I wouldn’t be surprised to find a similar failure on the upper part of this same channel/area, given the distortion of the metal around this corner…


Oil Cooler with bottom section removed


Closeup of the failure


Swollen section

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Jan 19, 2018 4:25 pm

by Rynoth

Noel, where did you get your oil cooler from?

I think it’s worth mentioning that the top-mount oil cooler is not an Aeroconversions-sourced part, rather you have to buy them from a 3rd party. Any of us with top-mount oil coolers on an Aerovee or Aerovee Turbo might very well have coolers that come from different places.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Jan 19, 2018 4:40 pm

by NWade

Rynoth wrote:Noel, where did you get your oil cooler from?

I think it’s worth mentioning that the top-mount oil cooler is not an Aeroconversions-sourced part, rather you have to buy them from a 3rd party. Any of us with top-mount oil coolers on an Aerovee or Aerovee Turbo might very well have coolers that come from different places.

This is correct, and I don’t believe I’ve indicated otherwise in my previous comments on this thread.

As for the source of my original part, it came from CB Performance (as recommended in the AeroVee Turbo assembly manual). I’ve purchased a replacement from another source, via Amazon but looking at them side by side I can tell its the same part. I will say that the replacement part does look like it was handled more-gently than the one I got from CBP, though.

Take care,

–Noel

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Jan 20, 2018 3:23 am

by lutorm

Nice forensic work there!

The oil system thread at thesamba that I posted earlier measured an oil flow of ~1gpm at idle with the stock 26mm oil pump. That’s 0.6l over 10s. If you really blew a quart of oil out (and it didn’t just look like it), either basically the entire flow from the oil pump must have gone out that hole, or your pump flows a lot more oil. Did you notice what the oil pressure gauge read with the leak in progress?

You don’t happen to have a larger oil pump, do you? Edit: I missed you saying the Turbo has a different, dual oil pump earlier. I guess it’s worth checking if the sections are larger than 26mm, since it appears (again from that oil pressure discussion) that for pumps larger than 26mm, the relief passage is too small and you really end up spiking pressure with the oil cold, even with the relief plunger wide open.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Jan 20, 2018 2:31 pm

by Area 51%

Actually, Sonex does source and stock coolers these days. We got one off their shelf when we were there in Oct.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Mar 09, 2018 3:50 am

by lutorm

I’m curious if you ever got around to trying the 15w-40 oil and if you saw any differences in oil pressure.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Mar 09, 2018 11:47 am

by NWade

lutorm wrote:I’m curious if you ever got around to trying the 15w-40 oil and if you saw any differences in oil pressure.

I’ve been caught up in a job-search lately (anybody here need an IT Director?) - but I should be giving the engine a run this weekend and will report my results!

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Mar 09, 2018 11:53 pm

by lutorm

Cool, let me know. I’m getting close to starting my rebuilt engine and I’m thinking of trying 15w-40 or even 10w-30 to see what happens.

Not sure what you do. We apparently need an Information Security Operations Manager


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Mar 10, 2018 4:34 am

by NWade

lutorm wrote:Cool, let me know. I’m getting close to starting my rebuilt engine and I’m thinking of trying 15w-40 or even 10w-30 to see what happens.

PM Sent! And I’ll post here publicly with data as soon as my engine runs this weekend.

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2018 1:53 pm

by NWade

Brief update: Tried to run the engine this weekend, but my EarthX battery failed before the engine could turn over. The Fault Indicator LED is flashing in a pattern not described in any of their manuals, and the voltage across the terminals is fluctuating between 12.9 and 13.7 volts in sync with the LED flashing… its very odd! Tests on the aircraft with an AC-DC power supply show the avionics and panel functioning fine, with no blown fuses or other obvious faults. Attempts to reset the EarthX fault detection system with chargers and other batteries wired in parallel haven’t worked. I’m waiting to hear back from EarthX tech support, and don’t have a secondary battery I can use for starting the engine.

If anyone has recommendations on a secondary battery I could buy that won’t cost another $400, I’m all ears! The big catch is that my firewall & battery box are laid out for a small form factor battery (the current battery box is sized for an ETX680C).

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2018 2:44 pm

by SonexN76ET

Noel,

If you want to try an alternate or temporary battery until you get the issues with your EarthX battery worked out, I have had good service from my Odyssey 625 battery. It is $117 and weighs a little over 13 lbs. Many Motorsports suppliers sell them. I have heard good things about the EarthX and I hope you are able to get it straightened out with the help of EarthX technical support. Please let me know how it goes. I may go with the EarthX for my next battery.

Jake


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2018 8:12 pm

by floridasonex

I experienced an oil cooler failure in the air shortly after takeoff. Fortunately I was close enough to the airport I could reduce power
and return immediately. Waiting until you have 100 deg oil temp isn’t enough. That’s what I did.
My solution was a bypass valve that doesn’t let the oil go thru the cooler until it hits 185 degrees.

RT


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2018 4:21 am

by SNX1508

I am also using an Odyssey 625 battery. I had an ETX900 installed for a short time for the weight savings, but the ETX failed for unknown reasons with 0 volts out. I could reset the fault and it would be ok for awhile, but it would then fault again within a weeks time with 0 volts out. All of this during extended downtime while working on the AeroVee cylinder heads, so fortunately no in flight failure. EarthX replaced the battery & paid shipping both ways, but everyone be aware that the EarthX warranty policy is to provide only a single replacement for each battery purchased. So if mine fails again, no free replacement will be possible. That’s OK, the replacement has been sitting on a shelf since I received it, but its an expensive paper weight because I am afraid it will fail in flight.

Terry
Sonex #1508
N296SX
AeroVee #0736
Tail Dragger
http://www.mykitlog.com/SNX1508

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2018 2:04 pm

by bakerde36

I may get blasted here but I have been using the Advanced auto Life battery that they sell for motorcycles. I have had it since Oct 2016 and still going strong. It is the autocraft and I used the LFP-4 I got it for 120 dollars with the 20% percent online discount.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 1:20 am

by NWade

Small update: I got the warranty replacement battery from EarthX and started the engine today. No problems cranking her up.

The new 150 psi oil-pressure sender is reporting 150psi at engine idle, even with 10-40w oil and with the airplane sitting inside a 70 degree hangar for 2 hours before starting her up. So after idling for ~15-20 seconds I shut the engine down. I checked the sender body & wire-terminal with an Ohm-meter after shutting down the engine and am getting near zero resistance (and get the same reading when using the engine block or aircraft skin as a ground)… But I’m not convinced the sender is correct. It does climb up through a range of pressures if I crank the starter with the mags & coils off; but even then it quickly jumps up over 100 psi. AFAIK the VDO senders use the same ~180 ohm range regardless of the max PSI they read, so my MGL RDAC sensor configuration should be OK. The “Diagnostics” screen of my EFIS is showing some kind of value next to the Oil Pressure sender readout, but it seems way too high to be listing the raw Ohms.

I can’t imagine what might be blocked or clogged that could cause such high oil pressure, and the oil cooler did not distort or rupture. I’m going to try to switch back to the 80 psi (known-good) sender and see if it maxes out as well. I’m also going to hand-rotate the prop and ensure I’m getting a good amount of oil return into the crankcase at the oil fill port (to see if I can discern whether something is choking the oil flow through the system).

As always, I’m open to thoughts and suggestions!

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 1:43 am

by lutorm

NWade wrote:Small update: I got the warranty replacement battery from EarthX and started the engine today. No problems cranking her up.

The new 150 psi oil-pressure sender is reporting 150psi at engine idle, even with 10-40w oil and with the airplane sitting inside a 70 degree hangar for 2 hours before starting her up. So after idling for ~15-20 seconds I shut the engine down. I checked the sender body & wire-terminal with an Ohm-meter after shutting down the engine and am getting near zero resistance (and get the same reading when using the engine block or aircraft skin as a ground)… But I’m not convinced the sender is correct. It does climb up through a range of pressures if I crank the starter with the mags & coils off; but even then it quickly jumps up over 100 psi. AFAIK the VDO senders use the same ~180 ohm range regardless of the max PSI they read, so my MGL RDAC sensor configuration should be OK. The “Diagnostics” screen of my EFIS is showing some kind of value next to the Oil Pressure sender readout, but it seems way too high to be listing the raw Ohms.

I can’t imagine what might be blocked or clogged that could cause such high oil pressure, and the oil cooler did not distort or rupture. I’m going to try to switch back to the 80 psi (known-good) sender and see if it maxes out as well. I’m also going to hand-rotate the prop and ensure I’m getting a good amount of oil return into the crankcase at the oil fill port (to see if I can discern whether something is choking the oil flow through the system).

As always, I’m open to thoughts and suggestions!

–Noel

That’s weird. Assuming the sensor if not totally out of whack (do you have a compressed air source you can screw it into and get a sanity check?) it seems hard to imagine getting that high pressure without blocking at least the pressure relief valve. It’s supposed to open at 40 psi, I think.

Do you have one of those bypass plates you mount where the top-mounted oil cooler goes if you use a bottom-mounted one? If you replace the oil cooler with a bypass and you still have 150psi at idle then it seems the oil passages must be seriously blocked. If you have lower pressure without the cooler then it seems likely the pressure relief plunger is stuck closed and that’s just the pressure it takes to push the cold oil through the cooler.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 9:53 am

by GWMotley

Noel,
If using an MGL extreme for example, be sure to look under the EMS setup for the type of oil pressure unit used and then the next step to check would be to verify the pressure bar setting which could be set to 2 , 5 or 10. Even if you don’t think it may have changes it is a simple check to confirm that it matches the bar rating stamped on the sender.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:48 pm

by pete 212

Noel you will find the problem at the rear oil relief the piston is seeing 150+before it opens, there is a chart on here that explains the system and the cure, I would dremel a small X across the top of the piston to get the oil across the whole area of the piston which will bring the opening pressure way down, we had to do this on hydraulic cyls for the same reason, I had 250 in my system that blew 2 oil coolers 1 oil press sender and 2 oil filters, hope this helps. Pete212


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 6:34 pm

by NWade

pete 212 wrote:Noel you will find the problem at the rear oil relief the piston is seeing 150+before it opens

Pete wins the prize for guessing the proper component/problem! Unfortunately he’s wrong about the reason: Somehow the piston/plunger is jammed at the top of its travel.

I swear I tested this plunger for full travel in the case, before assembling the engine. However, it appears that somehow inserting it with the tension of the spring behind it has caused it to become stuck!

The darned thing will not come out, no matter how much I try to cajole it with various picks and pry-tools. I’ve tried gently heating the crankcase and tapping with a rubber mallet, I’ve read online that an M10 tap can be screwed into the underside of the plunger but an M10 appears to be too small of a diameter for my plunger… I tried removing the spring, reinstalling the plug, and cranking the starter until I saw 80+ PSI on the oil-pressure gauge. But when I removed the plug I found that the plunger still hadn’t budged… Gah!

Anyone have any bright ideas? I’m thinking I might have to slowly/carefully drill a hole through the plunger and then try to use that hole to pull the thing down - but I’m worried about getting metal chips up in the engine and don’t want to destroy the plunger if I can avoid it.

Thanks,

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 7:37 pm

by kevinh

Hi Noel,

This tool will probably do it for you: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Oil-Piston-Pul … 2749.l2649. It allows you to apply a sizable amount of pressure to grip the plunger from the inside.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 7:42 pm

by Area 51%

CB performance sells a piston removal tool, as do most other VW parts suppliers. The part number is 6549. It’s $14 plus shipping.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 7:46 pm

by lutorm

When mine was stuck, I got it out with compressed air. However, I had to plug ALL the oil passages with wads of tissue paper before it would build up enough pressure to come out, which will be hard in your situation. You can access the side of that plunger by pulling out the freeze plug at the rear of the case, but if it’s really at the top of its travel you can’t get to the top. And pulling the freeze plug requires tapping for a new plug and you can’t do that with the plunger in place. It would also put chips everywhere…

I guess you can try starting it, letting it idle, and watch for a sudden drop in oil pressure that indicates it’s come loose. I don’t know what pressure you’d have with the plunger fully out, but If you turn it off quickly I doubt there would be any adverse effects.

Edit: that tool looks like the way to go though.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 8:08 pm

by NWade

All -

Thanks, I’ve already ordered the puller tool from CBP. Was curious if anyone had a different idea that was faster than waiting for the part to ship; but I guess I’ll have to wait.

–Noel

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 8:24 pm

by Rynoth

NWade wrote:Was curious if anyone had a different idea that was faster than waiting for the part to ship; but I guess I’ll have to wait.

–Noel

I’ve removed my plunger once by taking a 1/2 inch wooden dowel, cutting out a notch in the tip of it with my band saw, then inserting a little wooden wedge into the new notch, as in this photo:

http://www.rynoth.com/wordpress/wp-cont … x-2795.jpg

The dowel is just a little bit smaller than the inside diameter of the plunger, but when I tapped the other end of the dowel with a mallet, it pushed the wedge into the notch and expanded the dowel within the plunger, giving me a solid grip on the plunger, which I then removed.

http://www.rynoth.com/wordpress/wp-cont … x-2803.jpg

Some version of this might work for you while you wait for the removal tool. I’m also still having high oil pressure (80+ psi) issues in my Turbo Aerovee and will be performing this procedure once again soon, in the search for a smoking gun.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 10:13 pm

by daleandee

Rynoth wrote:I’ve removed my plunger once by taking a 1/2 inch wooden dowel, cutting out a notch in the tip of it with my band saw, then inserting a little wooden wedge into the new notch, as in this photo:

http://www.rynoth.com/wordpress/wp-cont … x-2795.jpg

The dowel is just a little bit smaller than the inside diameter of the plunger, but when I tapped the other end of the dowel with a mallet, it pushed the wedge into the notch and expanded the dowel within the plunger, giving me a solid grip on the plunger, which I then removed.

http://www.rynoth.com/wordpress/wp-cont … x-2803.jpg

That’s a great tip/trick that you shared there. Thanks!

8~)

Dale Williams
N319WF @ 6J2
Myunn - “daughter of Cleanex”
120 HP - 3.0 Corvair
Tail Wheel - Center Stick
Signature Finish 2200 Paint Job
171.9 hours / Status - Flying
Member # 109 - Florida Sonex Association
Latest video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VP7UYEqQ-g


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 10:51 pm

by Rynoth

daleandee wrote:
That’s a great tip/trick that you shared there. Thanks!

I’d claim full credit but I learned that tip from somebody on this forum years ago, I was too lazy to go find the original post to link here.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 19, 2018 6:35 pm

by floridasonex

I blew a cooler in the air early on. They’re weak. I installed a thermal bypass valve that won’t allow
oil thru cooler until it hits 185 degrees. You can reduce the OP by putting a lighter spring in the rear
relief valve (by the flywheel). There are also variable adjusters made to go there.

RT


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Mar 24, 2018 8:28 pm

by NWade

Update: Well, I might be screwed. Although I swear I tested this oil plunger for free movement inside the oil passage before installing it into the engine permanently, it is wedged up inside the passage tight. Cranking the engine and putting 120psi of oil pressure on it won’t budge it. I bought a puller tool from CBP, but after using it for 2 hours all I managed to do was beat up my knuckles, swear a lot, scrape a lot of metal out of the inside of the plunger with the tool, and possibly mushroom the plunger with the tool. I got it to budge downward a small amount, but after being unable to move it any further over many attempts, I used a rubber mallet to tap it back upwards just a bit (to see if it would loosen, or in case it was cocked off at an angle and needed to straighten up) - and while it moved upwards a bit that also seems to have made it impossible for the plunger to move in either direction now. I am totally stumped!

Open to ideas that don’t mean pulling the engine off the airframe, tearing it down to its component parts, and possibly getting a new case half… sigh

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Mar 24, 2018 10:44 pm

by daleandee

NWade wrote:Update: Well, I might be screwed. Although I swear I tested this oil plunger for free movement inside the oil passage before installing it into the engine permanently, it is wedged up inside the passage tight.

Open to ideas that don’t mean pulling the engine off the airframe, tearing it down to its component parts, and possibly getting a new case half… sigh

Hi Noel,

A bit of a drastic approach but I’ve read where a small hole can be drilled into the plunger and a dent puller (slide hammer) is used to remove it.

FWIW,

Dale Williams
N319WF @ 6J2
Myunn - “daughter of Cleanex”
120 HP - 3.0 Corvair
Tail Wheel - Center Stick
Signature Finish 2200 Paint Job
171.9 hours / Status - Flying
Member # 109 - Florida Sonex Association
Latest video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VP7UYEqQ-g


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Mar 24, 2018 11:24 pm

by Rynoth

NWade wrote:Open to ideas that don’t mean pulling the engine off the airframe, tearing it down to its component parts, and possibly getting a new case half… sigh

–Noel

I can’t remember where I read this, but I believe a 1/4 NPT tap is just the right size to insert and bite into the bottom of the plunger, almost like a screw extraction tool, without scuffing up the gallery.

Those VW plunger extractors, while mine has worked well enough for me, they don’t have a good interface to bear down and get a really tight grip on the plunger, especially when they have residual oil on them. I wonder if you could grind away part of the outer shaft to enable yourself to get a wrench on it before cranking on the handle.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2018 8:11 pm

by Area 51%

My VW repair book (Bentley publications) recommends a 10mm tap into the plunger to remove them.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2018 8:31 pm

by pfhoeycfi

Area 51% wrote:My VW repair book (Bentley publications) recommends a 10mm tap into the plunger to remove them.

Hi curious about the Bentley manual. Could you provide the title? I googled Bentley VW and a list a mile long comes up. Thanks, sorry for jumping in…


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 26, 2018 8:42 am

by Area 51%

The manual I have is the “Volkswagen official service manual”. It covers the Beetle, Super Beetle, and Karmann Ghia from 1970-1979. It shows a Bentley stock number of V179 and a manufacturing code of V179-25.

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 26, 2018 10:39 am

by NWade

Area 51% wrote:My VW repair book (Bentley publications) recommends a 10mm tap into the plunger to remove them.

FWIW, a 10mm tap is too small for the pistons/plungers used on the AeroVee. A 1/2" tap is also just slightly too small. I believe a 17/32" or 14mm tap will be the appropriate size; but I’ll have to buy one to find out…

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 26, 2018 10:58 am

by Sonex422

I used a pipe tap because it is tapered. As I recall it was 1/4" (at worst it is 3/8"). That way exact dimension is not critical.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Mar 26, 2018 8:04 pm

by pfhoeycfi

Area 51% wrote:The manual I have is the “Volkswagen official service manual”. It covers the Beetle, Super Beetle, and Karmann Ghia from 1970-1979. It shows a Bentley stock number of V179 and a manufacturing code of V179-25.

Excellent…

thanks,

peter


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2018 7:53 pm

by NWade

The saga continues: I have successfully threaded a 14mm tap up into the bottom of the oil control piston. Sadly, however, I still cannot get it to budge more than about 2 mm up or down. I have tried using vice-grips to pull on the square end of the tap (both straight down and while rocking the tap in various directions), to no avail. I’ve also turned the tap until it is fully threaded into the piston and cannot turn anymore. Then I can use a lever and vice-grips to continue spinning the tap - spinning the piston with it. Unfortunately the piston will spin (with some resistance), but pulling downward on the vice-grip handle while doing so does not result in any progress beyond the ~2mm of travel.

Open to any and all bright ideas!

–Noel
P.S. Do other Aerovee owners notice what looks like a “sleeve” inside of the tube/galley that the oil control piston slides in? Here’s a photo - you can see the “sleeve” above the oil return hole.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2018 8:43 pm

by lutorm

Hm, that sucks. If you thread it in too far, you might be expanding the piston and jamming it into the bore. I’d tap it as little as possible, just enough to grip. I assume the area is already plenty oiled? If not, turn the engine over a little.

Maybe you can now thread in a long 14mm bolt into the piston and tighten a nut against some sort of washer sitting on the seat where the spring holder washer sits? That’s probably the best way to be able to apply significant pulling force straight out. (This is the method I used to get the oil passage plugs out to clean the case.)


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2018 8:15 am

by Area 51%

I have both an aluminum and an Aerovee case, and they both have that “step/sleeve-looking” aspect. I’m sure the step was induced during the threading operation for the plug.

Wanna buy the mag case?


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2018 1:20 pm

by NWade

Update: SUCCESS!

I was finally able to rig up a tool and forcibly pull the oil plunger out of the crankcase.

For posterity, here’s how I did it:

  1. With the oil plunger nearly immobile at the top of its travel, I used a 14mm tap [CAUTION: this would bite me in the butt later, be sure to read on] to carefully cut threads into the bottom of the oil plunger.
  2. I attempted to use the tap and a pair of vise-grips to twist and pull the plunger out, to no avail.
  3. I belatedly realized that the tap I used is 14mm x 1.25 - do not use that thread pitch! That is mostly used for spark plugs and it is nearly impossible to find bolts and nuts with that thread pitch. If you ever have to do this operation yourself, I recommend a 14mm x 2 or 14mm x 1.5 tap.
  4. Since a normal bolt was out of the question, I had to do a lot more purchasing and fabrication. I sourced some specialty nuts, a 14mm x 1.25 die, and a 9/16" aluminum rod.
  5. I carefully cut threads into the rod with the die, cut it to length (about 5"), chamfered both ends of the rod, and thoroughly cleaned it.
  6. I used a double-nut at one end of the rod, to give me something to clamp vise-grips onto - so that I could stop the rod from turning.
  7. I threaded another nut onto the rod, about 1" above the double-nut. I stacked 3 thick washers on top of the nut, as a bearing surface against the bottom of the crankcase. The shape of the case means you have to choose your washer size carefully; I believe I used 3/4" or 7/8" OD washers with a 9/16" ID.
  8. I used a small squirt of denatured alcohol up into the bore to wash out any metal particles and the remnants of my earlier attempts. I then applied a little bit of oil in the bore to lubricate the plunger as it was (hopefully) pulled down and out.
  9. I carefully inserted the rod up into the oil control bore and twisted it to thread the rod into the base of the oil plunger (which had previously been threaded with the tap). I threaded the rod as far as it would go, and then backed it off about 1/2 turn.
  10. I used my fingers to snug the washers and nut up against the bottom of the crankcase, then used an open-end wrench to “tighten” the nut while holding the rod from turning down at the double-nutted end. Since the nut & washers can’t move upwards against the crankcase, this has the effect of pulling the rod downwards - and the oil plunger with it.
  11. Because of the crankcase shape and the exhaust pipes, this was a very tedious process - I could only rotate the nut by 1 flat before removing and reseting the wrench. Slowly, however, the plunger began to move. Over 5-10 minutes I was able to pull the piston out completely with only minor scoring in the walls of the crankcase bore. [NOTE: the vertical scrapes you see in that last photo are from my earlier attempts to remove the plunger. The horizontal/circumferential grooves and ridges further up inside the bore are what appear to have been preventing the plunger from moving normally]
  12. I then used very fine-grit sandpaper on a dowel to smooth the inside of the bore. This was followed by careful squiring of denatured alcohol up into the bore to rinse things out (being careful to not wash too much of it back into the sump through the holes in the side of the bore). Thin clean rag material was used with a dowel to aid in removing any grit and metal particles. This cleaning process was a few times. In the end the bore isn’t perfect, but its a lot smoother and there are no raised ridges I can see.
  13. I took a fresh replacement oil plunger and used fine-grit sandpaper to smooth the chamfers around the circumference of both the top and bottom of the plunger. I used 1000-grit sandpaper to polish the outside wall of the plunger as well. Then it was thoroughly rinsed with thinner / denatured alcohol and dried.
  14. Although I had tried to clean up the ends of the oil control spring when I first assembled the engine, I doubled-down and did it again - using a small file to smooth the corners and ends of the spring. My concern here is that any sharp edges on the end of the spring could cause it to score the walls of the bore that the plunger slides in - and that could cause a bur or ridge that would jam the plunger. I ensured that both ends of the spring were filed in such a way as to prevent this scoring from happening (I did both ends so it wouldn’t matter which way the spring was inserted into the engine).
  15. Oil was coated onto the plunger and it was test-fit into the crankcase. First I put it in with my pinkie finger, slid it up as far as I could get it, then removed my finger and watched for it to fall out under gravity - which it did. Then I cleaned and re-oiled it, put it up inside the crankcase and used the oil control spring to push it to the top of its travel, and watched for it to fall out under gravity. It stuck momentarily, due to the surface tension of the oil, but then fell out. I then cleaned, oiled, and inserted the assembly with the plug screwed in to ensure spring tension pushed the plunger up to the top of its travel with some force. I then removed the plug and watched for the assembly to drop out due to gravity (I wasn’t taking any chances)… Again it stuck momentarily due to the oil; then fell freely out of the engine.
  16. Finally, I inserted the assembly, tightened the plug, refilled the engine oil, and let it settle into the sump for a few minutes.

After all of that, I cranked the starter (with all fuel & ignition modules off) while watching my oil pressure reading. After a few seconds of cranking, the oil pressure came up to ~30psi and stayed there. Huzzah! Ever since my early engine runs, I would see nearly 80 psi of oil when performing this check. At the time I blamed the 20W-50 oil and the fact that my hangar was only 40 degrees fahrenheit; but now I know it was due to the oil control plunger sticking.
I pulled out the fuselage, tied it down & chocked it, and started up the engine while my lovely wife watched for leaks and kept a fire-extinguisher handy. The engine started up easily and over ~60 seconds of idling between 800 and 1200 rpm the oil pressure remained between 35 and 58 psi (on a cold rainy evening).

Now its time to build the turbo cooling system, finish the canopy, the leg & tail fairings, and get this bird in the air!

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2018 1:25 pm

by Bryan Cotton

As we used to say at Sikorsky- it’s almost too easy! Congrats and good luck!


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2018 10:40 pm

by kevinh

congrats. nice write up!


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Apr 06, 2018 8:36 am

by Area 51%

Congratulations on your success. Your situation rings mildly of the Apollo 13 fiasco. A $3 part nearly mucking up the whole show.

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 4:01 am

by lutorm

Did you ever try the different viscosities? I just noticed that Great Plains recommends 10W-30 (or straight SAE30) for use with their Force One bearing.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 3:18 pm

by NWade

lutorm wrote:Did you ever try the different viscosities? I just noticed that Great Plains recommends 10W-30 (or straight SAE30) for use with their Force One bearing.

Yes, I’m using the 10W-40 grade of Brad-Penn oil.

I will point out that in the end, my oil cooler failure was probably not caused by using 20W-50 oil itself; rather the root cause was the oil control plunger sticking at the top of its travel.

Still, I am remaining with the 10W-40 for now since I am getting good oil pressure (40-60 psi) out of it in my ground runs, the plane will live in an unheated hangar, I was not provided with any specific red-flags (beyond needing to watch my oil pressure) when discussing this weight of oil with tech support personnel, and VW forum enthusiasts continue to strongly recommend avoiding 20W-50 in conjunction with the larger/up-rated oil pumps that are found on the Turbo (although I recognize that their experience with cars may not be directly applicable to an aircraft engine).
In short: I don’t believe it is likely to provide me much upside (other than occasional cold-weather operation). But I wasn’t able to discern any major risks/downsides to using 10W-40, either.

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat Apr 28, 2018 5:31 pm

by lutorm

Hmm… So I just got my Aerovee started after the rebuild (after some troubleshooting, see separate post) and I also have 90+psi (off-scale high) at startup idle. I’m even running Brad Penn 10W-30 for the moment. As the oil warmed up to 120F or so it dropped to the 80s at idle. I guess I’ll be taking a second look at my oil plungers, too…


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2018 1:31 pm

by NWade

lutorm wrote:Hmm… So I just got my Aerovee started after the rebuild (after some troubleshooting, see separate post) and I also have 90+psi (off-scale high) at startup idle. I’m even running Brad Penn 10W-30 for the moment. As the oil warmed up to 120F or so it dropped to the 80s at idle. I guess I’ll be taking a second look at my oil plungers, too…

Yes, I highly recommend doing so! That is almost exactly what I was seeing in my original situation. Good luck, and reply to this thread or private message me if you have questions or want further info on how I solved my issues.

NOTE: I want to reiterate that I recommend not using the specialty tool you can buy to extract the plungers. The little metal fingers that expand into the plunger can definitely cause the plunger to “bulge” against the interior passage and bind up even worse. If the plunger is stuck and simple methods don’t get it out, use an appropriate-sized tap. That method was effective & straightforward, and new plungers only cost a couple of dollars online.

Good luck!

–Noel


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2018 8:46 am

by Sonex422

Make sure that you double check your settings for the oil pressure sensor. I had a similar problem and determined that I used the wrong ratio (my MGL unit at the time had defaulted to Rotax settings which used a sensor with different resistance values). Your numbers look like they are twice that of the normal, same as mine originally. Correcting it solved my problem. I did confirm the umbers with an actual pressure test gage (harbor freight part).

Regards


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2018 4:45 pm

by lutorm

I think the pressure sensor is OK because before the rebuild we had ~45psi at cold idle. (And that was with 20W-50 oil, this is with 10W-30.)


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 2:13 am

by lutorm

Soo… i took out the spring and cranked the engine and the plunger came out, no problem. I started it without the plunger and got about 50 psi at idle. As the oil warmed up to 60C, this dropped to about 15psi. I still had about 80psi if I opened the throttle, so even with the oil control valve wide open you seem to get quite a high pressure.

So now I’m unsure of whether the plunger was truly stuck or if that’s just how strong the spring is… From what Pete212 said before, it seems he had a very high opening pressure for the valve.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 11:59 pm

by NWade

Which plunger did you check?


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 1:06 pm

by lutorm

NWade wrote:Which plunger did you check?

Both. The front came out with the spring. But I only ran it with the rear out because I wanted to isolate their effect on the oil pressure.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat May 05, 2018 4:10 pm

by lutorm

Ok, after removing the sensor I see it says “0-5bar” on it. I believe is is this guy: https://vdo-webshop.nl/en/pressure-senders/378-vdo-pressure-sender-0-5-bar-1-8-27-nptf.html.

Now, 5 bar is 72 psi and the specs say this sensor maxes out at 184ohm. The MGL is calibrated for a 200ohm sensor with max pressure 145psi. I guess this means the oil pressure has always been half of what we thought it was… In recordings from before the rebuild the oil pressure when hot came down to 17 psi, so that means it was actually 8.5 psi, at 3000 rpm. No wonder the bearings were bad, that’s really low!

Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sat May 05, 2018 6:57 pm

by SonexN76ET

Patrik,

I would recommend getting an oil pressure sender that corresponds with the settings on your MGL. I do not believe the readings you get with a sender that is different from your MGL will be linear. At least that was my experience when I tried a different sender when troubleshooting erroneous readings.

Jake


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun May 06, 2018 2:50 am

by lutorm

I just changed the full-scale reading from 145 to 72 psi and it appears to read just half of what it did before. I don’t see why the full-scale setting should affect linearity. (The resistance setting definitely will though, but as long as you actually set it to the correct value it should be fine.)


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 7:35 am

by Sonex422

Get one of these test units to verify your oil pressure readings.

https://www.harborfreight.com/engine-oi … 62621.html

This will give your peace of mind.


Re: Oil Cooler Structural Failure

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2018 9:37 am

by bvolcko38

Where is an OEM quality oil cooler available? Not a chineseium knock off.